The UK Civil Service

Facts, Analysis and Comment.

Integrity

The ‌Civil Service Code says that:

You must:

You must not:

Here is some additional practical advice on conflicts of interest and personal financial interests:

Conflicts of interest

Great care needs to be taken to avoid conflicts of interest, whether real or perceived. You may be certain that you could rise above them, but others will doubt it. All potential conflicts of interest, including conflicts with the interests of your immediate family, must therefore be disclosed to managers, remembering that an innocuous friendship, investment, gift or treat can be transformed overnight into a possible conflict of interest. The following paragraphs provide guidance, but nothing in them should be taken to detract from departmental guidance, which should be consulted, and taken to prevail, in case of doubt. Indeed, certain individual departments, or parts of departments, have additional requirements above those mentioned below.

(Much administrative law (i.e. judicial review) is concerned with conflicts of interest. Further advice is here.)

Gifts, hospitality etc.

These may be divided into three categories.

First, there are gifts from a company whose services you are using or might use, or with whom you might negotiate grant or other support, or which might materially benefit from decisions with which you might be involved. There are absolutely no circumstances in which you can accept a gift of any value, or any hospitality more substantial than a working lunch, from such a source. This prohibition extends to the use of Air Miles and other benefits offered by the travel trade etc.

Second, expensive gifts (each departments defines its own limit) from other donors must also generally be refused or returned. Alternatively, it is sometimes possible to say to the donor ‘Thank you for the gift which I will use in the office rather than for my personal use’. (You can donate wine to the Christmas party.) Failing this, you can hand the gift over to the department, or pay the department to let you keep it.

Third, any gifts, hospitality etc. whose acceptance is not prohibited under the first two rules above, should also be refused unless the acceptance can clearly be justified as contributing to the achievement of your objectives. Put another way, the reason for the acceptance has to be clearly defensible, always remembering the Greek proverb that ‘gifts are poison’.

Positive reasons for accepting hospitality include the need to carry out an ambassadorial role, make contacts and gain information. It is therefore generally OK to attend celebrations of a company’s success or longevity, or an industry-wide gathering, including trade association dinners. It is also reasonable to accept inexpensive gifts such as ties and pens, so as to avoid giving offence. Conversely, it is important to avoid developing a sense of obligation to a host or donor, and to avoid criticism (from those unable to benefit) of benefiting from lavish hospitality etc. In general, therefore, you should not accept tickets for major sporting events, Glyndebourne or Covent Garden. It is seldom a good argument that you are establishing or maintaining contacts at such events, because it is seldom appropriate or possible to discuss business. It is often useful to apply the ‘wow’ test. When you receive an invitation and find yourself saying ‘wow’ then it is time to refuse.

A similar approach should be adopted when considering whether you might be accompanied by a partner to an event. Indeed, the negative factors can be more intense, given that the cost to the host will have doubled, and the opportunity to do business will have diminished. On the other hand, it can be helpful to be accompanied by a partner to an event at which one is trying to build up a relationship with the host or to an event at which one is acting as an ambassador, for instance at a company celebration or an event in aid of charity.

It is usually acceptable to accept local transport, lunch and refreshments when visiting private sector companies. But you may never let a private sector company pay your rail fare, air fare or overnight hotel bill. It is also acceptable to accept overnight accommodation in a company’s guest house provided for that purpose, but of course you must not then claim overnight subsistence. And it is permissible to accept a free flight in a company plane if there is no convenient public transport and if the plane would have been making the journey anyway. But the offer of such transport should be refused if convenient public transport is available, or if the provision of the flight would cause the company to incur significant expense. 

Incidentally, the NAO published a report, in early 2016, on the acceptance of gifts etc. In general, the NAO found that the above rules were being observed, but they did criticise the acceptance of tickets to professional sports and cultural events, sometimes accompanied by a spouse and/or children; bottles of champagne; wine for a team’s Christmas lunch; and iPads. You have been warned!

Financial Interests

We must all take particular care to avoid profiting, or enabling others to profit, (or even getting into a position where we could do these things) from information which is supplied to us in confidence. In particular, you must consult your line manager if you are asked to handle papers concerning any company (including a bank) in which you have invested, or with which you have any financial link. (However, standard bank accounts may be ignored for this purpose, unless they contain a huge amount of money.) You must also tell your manager if you hold shares in, or have any other link with, any company which is dealt with by you or your colleagues. You must do this immediately on joining the team, or immediately on acquiring the shares etc. This applies even if the shares are held via a PEP or ISA. Holdings in collective vehicles such as OEICs and unit trusts need not be reported unless you have a large holding (over £1000) and you know that your trust has invested in a company or companies with which you are dealing.

You must also tell your line manager about any other employment or self-employment. And you must disclose links to all other bodies (including charities) if it looks as though you might be asked to deal with them on behalf of the department.

There are also strict rules about business appointments after retirement. It is obviously important that there should be no cause for any suspicion of impropriety when you take up a new job after retirement. All offers of employment should therefore be reported to your department who will if necessary involve the Advisory Committee on Business Appointments which gives advice on applications at the most senior levels, and reviews a wider sample in order to ensure consistency and effectiveness.